Who would you buy?

redfanman

TIA Regular
Joined
Apr 29, 2008
Messages
12,109
The difficulty is that next time the club are trying to sign a young player, or persuade in to sign a new contract, and are giving it the ‘work hard and put the hours in, and you’ll get chances’, the players representatives can say ‘did you say this to Harry Wilson too?’
Not every player is going to fit the requirements of the team - are you suggesting Klopp deliberately plays someone he doesn't think is ready or suitable, just so he can tell future signings that they will get chances or would you prefer him to be upfront about their opportunities?

Like @Kopstar says, under Klopp we can highlight that we are adding value with a number of young players we can show are going on to have good careers, even if they don't succeed here - we're not simply stock piling.
 

Kopstar

★★★★★
Joined
Jun 15, 2007
Messages
11,015
Not every player is going to fit the requirements of the team - are you suggesting Klopp deliberately plays someone he doesn't think is ready or suitable, just so he can tell future signings that they will get chances or would you prefer him to be upfront about their opportunities?

Like @Kopstar says, under Klopp we can highlight that we are adding value with a number of young players we can show are going on to have good careers, even if they don't succeed here - we're not simply stock piling.
It's also relevant to any potential signing that, as brutal as this may sound, Wilson wasn't signed by Klopp. There are bound to be players at the club before Klopp arrived who simply don't suit his style of play. That's not to say Wilson is one of them but if he doesn't get a shot in the first team then that's a reasonable explanation when in discussions with other potential future stars.
 

Anfield rd Dreamer

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 25, 2012
Messages
11,053
@Kopstar and @redfanman I think you are both missing the point. Klopps style and reputation is built on working hard and you'll get your chances. So far Wilson hasn't had a chance for the senior side. It doesn't matter whether he signed him or not, Wilson has done everything asked of him and passed every test he's been allowed to sit. Now if Klopp gives him a few chances next season before then letting him move on in Jan or next summer for being a poor fit, then that's fine. But to not give him a chance to see if he can adapt to Klopps needs during at least a 6 month period says that it isn't quite true about "work hard and you'll get your chance"! Klopp was reluctant to use Henderson further forward in his 3 man midfield and has admitted he had it wrong. Just because a player doesn't seem like they'd be able to suit a role doesn't mean they definitely won't be able to suit it. The only way to know if Wilson can play in a Klopp side is to give him a few chances. If it doesn't work he can move on. But to not give him the chance it seems a bit wrong.
 

ILLOK

In the Danger Zone.
Joined
Feb 10, 2009
Messages
15,388
Klopp has great judgement, a clear idea of what is necessary to play in this team and Wilson has been a Liverpool player for the 3 and a half years Klopp has been here.

He is in a perfect position to judge whether Wilson is suitable or not before he has given him a chance in the first team.
 

redfanman

TIA Regular
Joined
Apr 29, 2008
Messages
12,109
@Kopstar and @redfanman I think you are both missing the point. Klopps style and reputation is built on working hard and you'll get your chances. So far Wilson hasn't had a chance for the senior side. It doesn't matter whether he signed him or not, Wilson has done everything asked of him and passed every test he's been allowed to sit. Now if Klopp gives him a few chances next season before then letting him move on in Jan or next summer for being a poor fit, then that's fine. But to not give him a chance to see if he can adapt to Klopps needs during at least a 6 month period says that it isn't quite true about "work hard and you'll get your chance"! Klopp was reluctant to use Henderson further forward in his 3 man midfield and has admitted he had it wrong. Just because a player doesn't seem like they'd be able to suit a role doesn't mean they definitely won't be able to suit it. The only way to know if Wilson can play in a Klopp side is to give him a few chances. If it doesn't work he can move on. But to not give him the chance it seems a bit wrong.
Klopp had him train regularly with the first team a year ago. You make it sound like he's never met the bloke and the only way to know is to play him in the first team, which is simply not true.
 

Anfield rd Dreamer

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 25, 2012
Messages
11,053
"Hendo is a brilliant player," Klopp said.

"I’m really happy that he can show that again.

"He obviously likes the position. We've not used him there for one and a half years.

"Sorry about that!

"But we needed him there. A really good performance with brilliant passes."

If Klopp can admit he was wrong over his use of his captain (an almost ever present) I don't know why posters are surprised I'm saying he needs to see what Wilson can do on the pitch before deciding?
 

Scott Jones

Blunt
Joined
Mar 8, 2016
Messages
14,206
"Hendo is a brilliant player," Klopp said.

"I’m really happy that he can show that again.

"He obviously likes the position. We've not used him there for one and a half years.

"Sorry about that!

"But we needed him there. A really good performance with brilliant passes."

If Klopp can admit he was wrong over his use of his captain (an almost ever present) I don't know why posters are surprised I'm saying he needs to see what Wilson can do on the pitch before deciding?
TBH i took Klopps comments to be a little tongue in cheek.
 

Limiescouse

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 26, 2014
Messages
12,638
I agree with this.

He appears (from the outside looking in of course) to be a real professional. Trains hard, not put a word or facial expression out of place yet. Has impressed at every playing level he's been given a chance at.

Those saying about the difference between our level and the Championship seem to be assuming that's his level. I'm not sure why?

Just because he's impressed at Championship level (the highest he's played except, arguably, for Wales) doesn't mean he can't play higher. He needs to actually be tried higher for that to be found out.
I assume at least a portion of this is directed at me as it was me who made the comment about the disparity between the leagues. However, the rest of it is not remotely what I said.

The difficulty is that next time the club are trying to sign a young player, or persuade in to sign a new contract, and are giving it the ‘work hard and put the hours in, and you’ll get chances’, the players representatives can say ‘did you say this to Harry Wilson too?’
Good kids are given a chance to show what they have during training. They then earn their shot by forcing the manager’s hand by demonstrating they are better or have more to offer than other players the manager might otherwise pick. Doing well for Derby will get him invited back to try and earn a role. It is not sufficient to be given a role with the senior squad if he doesn’t then take the next step.
 

Kenny Dalglish LFC Legend

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 12, 2016
Messages
390
They are but also correct to admit Henderson has been more effective than expected when finally utilised further forward.
I think you are taking this out of context. Henderson did a job for us because we had no one else. Fabinho is now up to speed and Klopp is using Hendo further forward. Do you think if Fabinho got injured Henderson wouldn´t be used in the no.6?
Also you are contradicting yourself. You are saying from what I can see that Klopp is being stubborn over Wilson but wasn´t over Henderson. So what would be the reason for this? Is it personal? Does he not like Wilson? or maybe he thinks Wilson isn´t up to scratch at the moment.

Origi wasn´t getting a look in, now he´s 1st sub off the bench. Naby was used then benched and then all of a sudden was back in the first 11.

Klopp will do what he has to do.
 

Anfield rd Dreamer

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 25, 2012
Messages
11,053
I assume at least a portion of this is directed at me as it was me who made the comment about the disparity between the leagues. However, the rest of it is not remotely what I said.


Good kids are given a chance to show what they have during training. They then earn their shot by forcing the manager’s hand by demonstrating they are better or have more to offer than other players the manager might otherwise pick. Doing well for Derby will get him invited back to try and earn a role. It is not sufficient to be given a role with the senior squad if he doesn’t then take the next step.
I think some people are having different conversations here. I was addressing the fact that, as Mascot said, if Wilson isn't given a chance it's wrong because what else does he need to do? Well by your statement I'm guessing you believe he will be given that chance? "Doing well for Derby will get him invited back to try and earn a role. It is not sufficient to be given a role with the senior squad if he doesn’t then take the next step."
 

Anfield rd Dreamer

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 25, 2012
Messages
11,053
Klopp has never said he wouldn't be, so there is nothing to admit.
Fabinho and Henderson have both been available for many games. Klopp has only just used Henderson further forward. I don't know why he'd need to say anything? By his own admission Henderson has been asking to play further forward and Klopp has seemingly been resistant.
 

Anfield rd Dreamer

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 25, 2012
Messages
11,053
I think you are taking this out of context. Henderson did a job for us because we had no one else. Fabinho is now up to speed and Klopp is using Hendo further forward. Do you think if Fabinho got injured Henderson wouldn´t be used in the no.6?
Also you are contradicting yourself. You are saying from what I can see that Klopp is being stubborn over Wilson but wasn´t over Henderson. So what would be the reason for this? Is it personal? Does he not like Wilson? or maybe he thinks Wilson isn´t up to scratch at the moment.

Origi wasn´t getting a look in, now he´s 1st sub off the bench. Naby was used then benched and then all of a sudden was back in the first 11.

Klopp will do what he has to do.
Fabinho has been up to speed for months but Klopp was rotating him and Henderson. Why would me saying Henderson has been better than expected in the 8 mean he can no longer cover number 6? And im not saying Klopp is being stubborn over anything. It was a discussion over whether Klopp has to at least give Wilson a chance with us or not. My personal belief is he does have to and I think Klopp will. I'm disagreeing with people on here not Klopp who hasn't done one thing or the other yet.
 

Limiescouse

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 26, 2014
Messages
12,638
I think some people are having different conversations here. I was addressing the fact that, as Mascot said, if Wilson isn't given a chance it's wrong because what else does he need to do? Well by your statement I'm guessing you believe he will be given that chance? "Doing well for Derby will get him invited back to try and earn a role. It is not sufficient to be given a role with the senior squad if he doesn’t then take the next step."
And the idea I keep refuting is that "given a chance" means he gets games, a position which is predicated on doing well for Derby being sufficient to be given such a role in the quad. That just isn't the way this stuff works.
 

Anfield rd Dreamer

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 25, 2012
Messages
11,053
And the idea I keep refuting is that "given a chance" means he gets games, a position which is predicated on doing well for Derby being sufficient to be given such a role in the quad. That just isn't the way this stuff works.
There's never been any talk of him not training well enough. He seems to be a model pro. When he has got on the pitch he has done well at all levels. The only thing left is to see how he does at our level. Sink or swim time. Eventually we are going to have to use him or let him go. May get away with on a last loan to a premier league side but that just delays the decision to actually play him for us or sell him. If the issue, which is the only suggestion I've seen put forward, is that he can't play for us as he doesn't fit then it's pointless to loan him out again. Nobody plays quite like us so that question will still be unanswered when he comes back whether he does well or not.
 

ILLOK

In the Danger Zone.
Joined
Feb 10, 2009
Messages
15,388
"Hendo is a brilliant player," Klopp said.

"I’m really happy that he can show that again.

"He obviously likes the position. We've not used him there for one and a half years.

"Sorry about that!

"But we needed him there. A really good performance with brilliant passes."

If Klopp can admit he was wrong over his use of his captain (an almost ever present) I don't know why posters are surprised I'm saying he needs to see what Wilson can do on the pitch before deciding?
Where did Klopp admit he was wrong?
 

redfanman

TIA Regular
Joined
Apr 29, 2008
Messages
12,109
We've not used him there for one and a half years, sorry about that. All the articles are talking about how Henderson has been asking for it. Fabinho has been established for months now.
Fabinho hasn't though, because Klopp has still picked Hendo over him in key games which suggests either his fitness or control is still not quite where Klopp wanted.

This doesn't mean he hasn't considered Hendo as a more attacking option, only that he feels Hendo has provided him with something defensively that he prioritised.
 

Limiescouse

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 26, 2014
Messages
12,638
There's never been any talk of him not training well enough. He seems to be a model pro.
Again, not what I am saying. I am not claiming he is does not put the work in.

The only thing left is to see how he does at our level. Sink or swim time.
No. The intermediate step is to come back and demonstrate in training that he has more to offer than the likes Lallana, Origi, Shaq or anyone else we might buy in his position. He can be a model pro and have done wonderfully well in the championship and come back and not be able to demonstrate that because its a really high bar to have to pass. If that happens he will not play. And if that happens it will not mean that Klopp has not given him a chance.
 

ILLOK

In the Danger Zone.
Joined
Feb 10, 2009
Messages
15,388
We've not used him there for one and a half years, sorry about that. All the articles are talking about how Henderson has been asking for it. Fabinho has been established for months now.
I think you're taking Klopp's self effacing remarks a bit too seriously.

I think it gets forgotten just how many injury issues Henderson has had since Klopp has been the manager. Now we have a better player for the 6 role and Henderson has proven his fitness he is getting chances in the box to box role. Klopp knows what he's doing.

Also, let's not forget that we used a 4231 for a good chunk of the season.
 

Koon

Very bad englando. I'm so sorry.
Joined
Jan 10, 2016
Messages
379
I haven't watched a single Derby game this season, so all my thoughts are based on compilations from Wilson.

I don't think he is a playmaker, I think he is a goalscorer, from free-kicks and long range shoothing. And he is really good, would probably be the best in our squad in these aspects,, but I think he (still) lacks all the rest.

I don't see good dribbling and most important, I don't see a crispy pass or great team play from him. Also, he is not very pacey, so he would have to bring something else to the table, which should be playmaking skills (like Shaqiri) or some high energy and physicality (like Henderson/Milner).

I'm not saying by any means that Wilson isn't or won't become a great player, but I don't think he is on a PL winning team level just yet. If all he has are great long range shoothing and free kicks, these are secondary abilities, it should just complement a player's set of skills, not be his only traits.

Klopp and his staff know a lot more about him and also about Grujic, Woodburn, Curtis Jones and so on. We will see what they are planning.
 



Anfield rd Dreamer

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 25, 2012
Messages
11,053
Mignolet is a model pro. Does he deserve another chance?
Wilson doesn't even have a role level with Mignolet, I'm suggesting Klopp should, and will, give him a similar style back up role so Wilson can play for us before deciding he's a poor fit and selling him. Mignolet has played under Klopp. We know he is a poor fit. Wilson hasn't it's only assumption to say he's a poor fit.
 

Anfield rd Dreamer

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 25, 2012
Messages
11,053
Fabinho hasn't though, because Klopp has still picked Hendo over him in key games which suggests either his fitness or control is still not quite where Klopp wanted.

This doesn't mean he hasn't considered Hendo as a more attacking option, only that he feels Hendo has provided him with something defensively that he prioritised.
So why wasn't Henderson used in a more attacking CM role in the games Fabinho was trusted as the number 6 for? Surely if Klopp had those doubts over Fabinho then it'd make using Henderson, the most defensive 8 option, even more of a good idea? Klopp has admitted to viewing Henderson as purely a 6 I'm not sure why I'm getting argued with? It's simply a case of Klopp being human, improving as he goes. Open to admit the possibility of being wrong on something, trying it, learning from it and adapting in a positive way to things he didn't expect. Too many managers limit themselves by being stubborn. It's people on here pigeon holing Wilson as a player Klopp can't possibly work with. We don't know what Klopp thinks on it but I doubt he agrees.
 

Mascot88

Yours for £1m. Need to make room for Dean Saunders
Admin
Joined
May 24, 2007
Messages
19,918
The point I’m making is not Wilson is good enough for LFC, or Wilson should get starts. It’s that his Derby form gives Klopp a problem. That’s it.

Wilson has gone on loan twice and done everything asked of him, he has become a favourite at Derby and got himself into the Wales squad.

Klopp now has to consider whether he brings him back and integrates him into the first team set up, sends him out on loan again, or sells him. Both of the latter two options might be right for the club and Wilson himself, but present a complexity when sending any other lads out on development loans, as they will surely look at how well Wilson did and how it did nothing for his chances of making it at Liverpool. Klopp might reason that, even if his suspicion is that Wilson is a bit lacking at the highest level he needs to find him a first team role for the benefit of every other lad he wants to send out for experience.
 

Limiescouse

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 26, 2014
Messages
12,638
Klopp has admitted to viewing Henderson as purely a 6 I'm not sure why I'm getting argued with? It's simply a case of Klopp being human, improving as he goes. Open to admit the possibility of being wrong on something, trying it, learning from it and adapting in a positive way to things he didn't expect.
No he hasnt. He said pretty much the opposite, that he has played Hendo there because we had to for the good of the team (insinuation that he knew it was a role change, but did it because we didnt have anyone else who could play the role).
 

Anfield rd Dreamer

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 25, 2012
Messages
11,053
Again, not what I am saying. I am not claiming he is does not put the work in.



No. The intermediate step is to come back and demonstrate in training that he has more to offer than the likes Lallana, Origi, Shaq or anyone else we might buy in his position. He can be a model pro and have done wonderfully well in the championship and come back and not be able to demonstrate that because its a really high bar to have to pass. If that happens he will not play. And if that happens it will not mean that Klopp has not given him a chance.
All of which Klopp has tried out on the pitch. You can't know what someone can deliver on the pitch purely from training. And this comes back to mascots original point. Klopp can't say "train hard and you'll get your chance" if he isn't actually giving players chances. As I said I think you are wrong and Klopp will give Wilson chances on the pitch for us before ending his time here