• This website uses cookies. More information.
  • The This Is Anfield Forums community is moving to a new home. Click here for more information on the transition.

Who would you buy?

Status
Not open for further replies.

KYRed18

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 16, 2018
Messages
272
Sancho's last request before agreeing to personal terms....I want the Boss to be here a couple years longer..... Edwards/Klopp "funny you should say that, see this twitter video" :LOL::LOL::LOL:
 

SirBillShankly

We live in a fallen world.
Joined
Jan 8, 2011
Messages
10,843
I would buy Lewis Dunk.

With Lovren injury more serious and Matip out I would like to see us bring this fella in. Superb defender.
 

SirBillShankly

We live in a fallen world.
Joined
Jan 8, 2011
Messages
10,843
Matip is back in 2 weeks isn't he?
Is he? I don't think anybody really knows do they? But his return isn't set in stone. Lovren out aswell. Ditto Fabinho. I really think it's too soon for Van Den Berg and Hoever. Who else can play CB?

Okay, Dunk with a reported pricetag of £60m won't happen but I think we would be wise to bring in an experienced Klavanesque signing.
 

Sweeting

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jun 2, 2008
Messages
10,293
Is he? I don't think anybody really knows do they? But his return isn't set in stone. Lovren out aswell. Ditto Fabinho. I really think it's too soon for Van Den Berg and Hoever. Who else can play CB?

Okay, Dunk with a reported pricetag of £60m won't happen but I think we would be wise to bring in an experienced Klavanesque signing.
18 month left on contract according to Transfermarkt.co.uk
Upamecano, 21, Leipzig
Ginter, 25, Monchengladbach
Elvedi, 23 Monchengaldbach
Badiashile, 18, Monaco
Sarr, 20, Nice

Potentially could move for one of them in the summer. I don't watch those leagues so don't know how good they are but certainly Upamecano has recieved a lot of praise in the media and the two Monchengladbach players are sitting top of the Bundesliga.
 

Craig_Johnston

I'm very down under, but my wife disagrees
Joined
Apr 28, 2019
Messages
427
Hopefully in the summer we'll bring in a CB and let Lovren go. He has been a great servant despite his occasional mishaps, but the real issue is fitness. He never seems to last more than a dozen games without breaking down in some way or another. Gomez and Matip are injury prone too, but they are better players when fit.
 

Dave-D

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 10, 2014
Messages
3,900
Hopefully in the summer we'll bring in a CB and let Lovren go. He has been a great servant despite his occasional mishaps, but the real issue is fitness. He never seems to last more than a dozen games without breaking down in some way or another. Gomez and Matip are injury prone too, but they are better players when fit.
Agree on letting him go but mainly due to injuries and his age, he’ll be 31 come the start of next season which ain’t a spring chicken as a Liverpool defender.
 

redfanman

TIA Regular
Ad-free Member
Joined
Apr 29, 2008
Messages
15,932
Hopefully in the summer we'll bring in a CB and let Lovren go. He has been a great servant despite his occasional mishaps, but the real issue is fitness. He never seems to last more than a dozen games without breaking down in some way or another. Gomez and Matip are injury prone too, but they are better players when fit.
The club were willing to let him go this summer. I dont see them having a problem letting him go next year if there isnt a number of CBs out injured or demanding a move from the club. Particularly if our forwards and midfield need no other signings. I'm hoping that Wijnaldum will sign a new deal, he is perhaps the last of the regular players not to have signed one i think.
 

Richard88

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 7, 2017
Messages
649
Next summer I expect to see the following outgoings:

Lovren (31) will probably be allowed to move on next summer with 1 year remaining on his contract. Hoever will hopefully be ready to take his place in the squad by then.

Lallana (31) and Clyne (28) will most certainly be released when their contracts expire in 2020. Lallana's limited squad role can easily be filled by Jones and Minamino going forwards.

Grujic's future seems to be elsewhere and it wouldn't be surprising to see him loaned again, or even sold.

I'd also be surprised if Wilson isn't sold next summer. Klopp's latest quotes about him being a good player but needing to learn to link with teammates suggests to me that he's not in Klopp's plans.

Those outgoing transfers would leave the squad for 2020/21 as follows:

---------------------------- Alisson (27) --------------------------------
---------------------------- Adrian (32) ---------------------------------
---------------------------- Grabara (20) --------------------------------
---------------------------- Kelleher (21) -------------------------------

Trent (21) ------ Matip (28) ------- Van Dijk (28) ---- Robertson (25)
Hoever (17) --- Gomez (22) ------ Vd Berg (17) ------- (Milner)
Williams (18)

--------------------------- Fabinho (26) --------------------------------
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------- Wijnaldum (29) ---------------- Henderson (29) -------------
------------ Keita (24) ----------------------- Ox (26) -------------------
----------- Milner (33) --------------------- Jones (18) -----------------

Salah (27) ---------------- Firmino (28) -------------------- Mané (27)
Shaqiri (28) ---------------- Origi (24) ----------------- Minamino (25)
Elliott (17) ---------------- Brewster (19) -------------------------------

What I think the squad lacks mostly are young understudy's for Fabinho and Robertson, though in the short-term Milner and Henderson can cover those roles. Ideally we can bring in a left sided version of Hoever for LB, and someone like Sander Berge who can play DM and cover in CB.

Minamino's versatility makes it hard to predict whether we'll go after an AM or another wide forward next summer. Another attacking signing may also depend on whether or not Shaqiri stays. There should be a huge amount of money available next summer for a splash in the forward positions should Klopp want to do something; perhaps like changing Shaqiri and Origi into one more prolific player, like Timo Werner or another top attacker.
 

GermanRed

from doubters to believers to sky-high achievers
Joined
Jan 26, 2017
Messages
4,906
Don’t think Hoever/SvdB will be able to replace Lovren until Summer 2021.

If Lovren leaves someone has to be brought in - even if it is 'just' a Caulker/Klavan type of signing. Ideally it would be someone who knows the league or with international experience.
 

SirBillShankly

We live in a fallen world.
Joined
Jan 8, 2011
Messages
10,843
Wonder if we could bring in Cahill from Palace? Think he would be a decent stop gap.

Kristensen the Salzburg defender and Sander Berge look like very attractive propositions right now.

Cheap, classy and 1.95m bit of a no brainer with Fabinho out for a while yet. With his height maybe he could be an emergency CB aswell? Really feel we need a defensive signing now.

Kristensen, the Salzburg defender looked very,very accomplished against us. Hope Edwards is busy behind the scenes.
 
Last edited:

GermanRed

from doubters to believers to sky-high achievers
Joined
Jan 26, 2017
Messages
4,906
Think we have 2 or more CBs out injured in December/January for the third year in a row now.
 

redbj

hurry up, July 1st, let's get the show on the road
Joined
Jun 23, 2003
Messages
18,244
Next summer I expect to see the following outgoings:

Lovren (31) will probably be allowed to move on next summer with 1 year remaining on his contract. Hoever will hopefully be ready to take his place in the squad by then.

Lallana (31) and Clyne (28) will most certainly be released when their contracts expire in 2020. Lallana's limited squad role can easily be filled by Jones and Minamino going forwards.

Grujic's future seems to be elsewhere and it wouldn't be surprising to see him loaned again, or even sold.

I'd also be surprised if Wilson isn't sold next summer. Klopp's latest quotes about him being a good player but needing to learn to link with teammates suggests to me that he's not in Klopp's plans.

Those outgoing transfers would leave the squad for 2020/21 as follows:

---------------------------- Alisson (27) --------------------------------
---------------------------- Adrian (32) ---------------------------------
---------------------------- Grabara (20) --------------------------------
---------------------------- Kelleher (21) -------------------------------

Trent (21) ------ Matip (28) ------- Van Dijk (28) ---- Robertson (25)
Hoever (17) --- Gomez (22) ------ Vd Berg (17) ------- (Milner)
Williams (18)

--------------------------- Fabinho (26) --------------------------------
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------- Wijnaldum (29) ---------------- Henderson (29) -------------
------------ Keita (24) ----------------------- Ox (26) -------------------
----------- Milner (33) --------------------- Jones (18) -----------------

Salah (27) ---------------- Firmino (28) -------------------- Mané (27)
Shaqiri (28) ---------------- Origi (24) ----------------- Minamino (25)
Elliott (17) ---------------- Brewster (19) -------------------------------

What I think the squad lacks mostly are young understudy's for Fabinho and Robertson, though in the short-term Milner and Henderson can cover those roles. Ideally we can bring in a left sided version of Hoever for LB, and someone like Sander Berge who can play DM and cover in CB.

Minamino's versatility makes it hard to predict whether we'll go after an AM or another wide forward next summer. Another attacking signing may also depend on whether or not Shaqiri stays. There should be a huge amount of money available next summer for a splash in the forward positions should Klopp want to do something; perhaps like changing Shaqiri and Origi into one more prolific player, like Timo Werner or another top attacker.

I haven’t seen Klopps comments on Wilson, but chances are if he’s telling him what parts of his game to work on in - in the media- he hasn’t given up on him by a long shot.

If Klopp was throwing out false platitudes, then I’d be more inclined to agree he’s done here.

Don’t watch enough non LFC football to really have a qualified opinion on the matter, but if the current chorus of him needing to work on his involvement during games are true, then I think that can be worked on.

Better he’s got good technical skill and posting good numbers than he has a perfect reading of the game but no end product in his first season in the PL.

It mirrors origi in a way, numbers, but more in game involvement required, and I think that’s just fine ( not perfect) for someone who at best, will be getting cameos for us next season.
 

Richard88

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 7, 2017
Messages
649
Don’t think Hoever/SvdB will be able to replace Lovren until Summer 2021.

If Lovren leaves someone has to be brought in - even if it is 'just' a Caulker/Klavan type of signing. Ideally it would be someone who knows the league or with international experience.
I agree about Hoever and Vd Berg, 2020 might be a bit early for them. I'm sure Edwards and Klopp have a logical plan for how to bridge Lovren and his replacement.
 

Richard88

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 7, 2017
Messages
649
Wonder if we could bring in Cahill from Palace? Think he would be a decent stop gap.

Kristensen the Salzburg defender and Sander Berge look like a very attractive propositions right now.

Cheap, classy and 1.95m bit of a no brainer with Fabinho out for a while yet. With his height maybe he could be an emergency CB aswell? Really feel we need a defensive signing now.

Kristensen, the Salzburg defender looked very,very accomplished against us. Hope Edwards is busy behind the scenes.
Agree on Kristensen, he did stand out a few times when defending against Mané 1v1 in particular. Looks to be a decent player, but I'm not sure he'd fancy his chances at a club which already has an undisputed 1st choice RB
 

EdWood

TIA Youth Team
Joined
Jun 2, 2011
Messages
5,985
The smart play would be to reinforce in January, less trhan ideal though that is. We need a backup DM and in a perfect world another CB. If Fabinho had been playing against Watford they would have had one solid chance of a goal instead of five, max. With a dedicated DM screening the back four we are far more difficult to break down. Gini's loss has just exacerbated the problem. As for the CB situation we have four first team CBs - in theory - the problem being that three of them are injury prone.
 

The Elusive 19th

TIA Youth Team
Joined
Jan 30, 2011
Messages
5,433
The smart play would be to reinforce in January, less trhan ideal though that is. We need a backup DM and in a perfect world another CB. If Fabinho had been playing against Watford they would have had one solid chance of a goal instead of five, max. With a dedicated DM screening the back four we are far more difficult to break down. Gini's loss has just exacerbated the problem. As for the CB situation we have four first team CBs - in theory - the problem being that three of them are injury prone.
Buying an LB frees up Milner to play in midfield. Which potentially allows us to put Gini or Fab (when they comeback from injury) in CB here and there. So getting an already established, decent LB who can give some rest to Robbo will have a knock on effect.
 

redfanman

TIA Regular
Ad-free Member
Joined
Apr 29, 2008
Messages
15,932
The smart play would be to reinforce in January, less trhan ideal though that is.
the smart play is only smart if the player we sign is of the right quality, and we see a use for them beyond January. If he only plays when Fab isnt available, then he isnt going to get many games. He would have to cover a number of positions probably to get the games to justify his signing.

I think Keita will do well enough in Gini's absence. Gini is someone who doesnt stay out for long, although may need managing for a longer period.
 

EdWood

TIA Youth Team
Joined
Jun 2, 2011
Messages
5,985
Agree about the quality issue which is why it's less than ideal timing. The fact remains though that Hendo/Keita would be playing out of position - like aginst Watford - and quite naturally won't be a effective as someone who knows the DM role - like against Watford. We WILL be exposed to counter attacks as things stand and against much better teams than we were on Saturday. VVD isn't looking like his old solid self because of this and we can't keep relying on AB to produce 'worldies' to keep the opposition out.
 

redfanman

TIA Regular
Ad-free Member
Joined
Apr 29, 2008
Messages
15,932
Agree about the quality issue which is why it's less than ideal timing. The fact remains though that Hendo/Keita would be playing out of position - like aginst Watford - and quite naturally won't be a effective as someone who knows the DM role - like against Watford. We WILL be exposed to counter attacks as things stand and against much better teams than we were on Saturday. VVD isn't looking like his old solid self because of this and we can't keep relying on AB to produce 'worldies' to keep the opposition out.
Hendo played there before Fabinho joined and we had solid performances. VVD looked strong before Fabinho joined, and has looked a little out of sorts when Fabinho played this season so i dont think it fair to put it own to the latters absence. I dont think these are valid justifications for a new signing. I think we would adapt quicker to using Hendo there than an incoming signing would to play in that position.
 

EdWood

TIA Youth Team
Joined
Jun 2, 2011
Messages
5,985
Hendo played there before Fabinho joined and we had solid performances. VVD looked strong before Fabinho joined, and has looked a little out of sorts when Fabinho played this season so i dont think it fair to put it own to the latters absence. I dont think these are valid justifications for a new signing. I think we would adapt quicker to using Hendo there than an incoming signing would to play in that position.
I don't mean to sound argumentative but who then plays in Hendo's position as he's moved? And if it's Keita, who then plays in his as he's moved? We are short in central midfield now.
 

Limiescouse

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 26, 2014
Messages
16,595
I don't mean to sound argumentative but who then plays in Hendo's position as he's moved? And if it's Keita, who then plays in his as he's moved? We are short in central midfield now.
We're really not. We've still got Hendo, Milner, Ox, Naby, Lallana and even Shaq depending on the approach. Maybe even Curtis Jones for some more time off the bench or the Monterrey game.
 
Last edited:

cipher

TIA New Signing
Joined
Jun 9, 2004
Messages
12
Personally, I'd like to see us sign one of the big young attacking talents as we start getting ready to transition to the next iteration of Klopp's squad. I don't want us waiting too long like it seems Man City has. Also, cover at CB is needed given what we've seen with injuries the last two winters.

Out
Origi - 35M
Wilson - 30M
Shaqiri - 30M
Lovren - 15M
Total - 110M

In
Havertz/Sancho - 100M
Soyuncu - 35M
Total - 130M

Combined with the Minamino signing this leaves us with three current squad players out and three replacements in...

Origi -> Havertz/Sancho
Shaqiri -> Minamino
Lovren -> Soyuncu

If we could also add another player who could cover the full backs then our squad would be better balanced going into next year which is a scary thought for everyone else.
 

Sweeting

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jun 2, 2008
Messages
10,293
I haven’t seen him, but if we are interested, it places a question mark over Larouci and Lewis. I do agree we need to strengthen in this position.
Lewis won't be a left back in the Premier League. If he is going to make it as a PL player he would have to play in midfield.
Our current crop of left backs is Larouci, Gallacher, Norris and Beck. Larouci and Norris are good prospects but they are also versatile and play a lot of different positions.
 

Dutch

Well-Known Member
Ad-free Member
Joined
Apr 8, 2015
Messages
2,481
It does not matter how much we speculate or tell who we want Klopp almost always seem to surprise us.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.